Best Maryland Crab Soup Restaurants in Annapolis-Local Crab
Now Go See It is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission.
We sampled the local Maryland crab soup at some of Annapolis’ top restaurants to bring you these top Annapolis Restaurants to add to your Maryland Itinerary.
Best Annapolis Restaurants for Crab Soup: (Jump To)
Watch The Food Tour on YouTube:
About Maryland Crab Soup
Annapolis revolves around three main crab soups. Maryland crab soup—the red—starts with a tomato and stock base, then loads in vegetables like corn, green beans, carrots, potatoes, and cabbage along with sweet blue crab. It should taste bright and peppery, with Old Bay or a similar spice blend carrying the heat instead of drowning the crab. Texture matters: vegetables should stay firm, not mushy, and the broth should stay brothy, not stewy.
Cream of crab is the dairy-based counterpart. Think velvety, lightly thickened, and crab-first, often finished with a dash of sherry. Good cream of crab stays smooth and rich without turning pasty or floury. You’ll sometimes see paprika or parsley on top, and you should still find real pieces of crab in the spoon, not just a crab-flavored cream.
Half-and-half is the local split bowl that mixes the two. The best versions keep the red’s acidity and spice while borrowing the cream’s body, landing on a warm, orange blend that still shows distinct crab flavor. If you’re deciding where your palate leans, start with a half-and-half to calibrate, then order a full cup of your winner.
A little bit of history. Maryland red crab soups show up in 19th-century regional cookbooks, built on garden vegetables and whatever crab the watermen brought in that day. Cream-style soups surged in popularity across the U.S. in the early–mid 20th century, and Maryland kitchens adapted that trend with blue crab and a light sherry finish. Old Bay—created in Baltimore in the late 1930s by spice blender Gustav Brunn—became the go-to seasoning and still anchors the profile in many bowls. The half-and-half likely grew out of diner and tavern culture: two pots on the line, one quick blend at service for guests who wanted both.
Airline Miles and Hotel Points 101
We share tips and tricks for credit card points and miles. These tools help us save money on our trips around the world by allowing us to accumulate airline and hotel points.
Boatyard Bar & Grill
Map: Google Maps
Website: Link
If you want a textbook bowl made by people who live and breathe the Bay, start at Boatyard. Their Maryland crab soup is built on a beef-broth base with tomatoes, potatoes, cabbage, peppers, and generous blue crab, plus a smoky nudge from bacon that sets it apart (Boatyard lists the full lineup right on the menu). It’s hearty without getting muddied, and it keeps enough spice to remind you where you are. Cream of crab here is equally popular, and you can ship both varieties nationwide if you end up daydreaming about a second round back home. The nautical dining room is busy in the best way, with locals mixing in after time on the water. Order a cup if you’re doing a crawl; get a bowl if this is your main event. If you’re planning activities, pair lunch here with a harbor sail or a guided history walk you can book through Viator or GetYourGuide.
McGarvey’s Saloon & Oyster Bar
Map: Google Maps
Website: Link
A long-running tavern in the middle of downtown, McGarvey’s is an easy stop between the docks and Main Street. Their trio is the move: Maryland red, cream of crab, and the half-and-half, all poured hot with plenty of jumbo lump. The red has a slight kick that cuts through the tomato and plays nicely with the vegetables, while the cream leans rich but not cloying. If you’re splitting with a friend, the half-and-half gives a quick read on what you like before committing to a bigger bowl. The raw bar’s good reputation brings a steady crowd. Prices are fair for the location, making this a repeatable spot if you’re staying nearby. If you’re building a full Annapolis day, reserve a Naval Academy tour, then circle back here for soup and oysters before sunset.
Check out our other posts about things to see and do in Annapolis or Maryland!
Or visit our Destinations page to be inspired.
O’Brien’s Oyster Bar & Seafood Tavern
Map: Google Maps
Website: Link
O’Brien’s is a right-by-the-water classic with a crab-heavy menu and a loyal following. Check the tavern menu and you’ll see Maryland crab soup up front, plus a cup of “half Maryland & half cream” for people who want it both ways. The red keeps a true vegetable profile and never turns watery; the cream side lands on the thicker, comfort-food end without going gluey. If you’re here on a weekend, the dining room hums with happy hour energy, but the soup comes out quick and consistent even when the place is packed. Order the half-and-half to compare in one cup, then decide what your next Annapolis bowl should be. Location-wise, you’re steps from boat tours and the Market Space—easy content if you’re shooting B-roll between bites.
We’re on YouTube!
The same great content without all the pesky reading!
Middleton Tavern
Map: Google Maps
Website: Link
One of Maryland’s oldest restaurants and a tourist magnet for good reason, Middleton still treats soup like a signature. The Maryland crab soup here is tomato-forward with fresh vegetables and jumbo lump, offered in a cup or bowl, and the kitchen keeps the seasoning restrained—great for purists who want the crab to carry the bite. The room leans historic, so it doubles as a simple “taste of Annapolis” stop that photographs well. If you like a louder Old Bay profile, ask for a shaker at the table and tune it to your taste. From here, you’re perfectly placed to hit State Circle or jump on a narrated cruise. It’s a smart first or last stop if you’re timing a tight itinerary.
Federal House Bar & Grille
Map: Google Maps
Website: Link
Federal House is the hangout that surprises with soup. Their award-winning cream of crab is rich, smooth, and loaded, and they also serve a Maryland vegetable crab if you prefer the tomato route. It’s the kind of bowl that holds up on a chilly day without feeling heavy at lunch. Portions are generous, so consider a cup if you’re stacking multiple tastings. If the patio’s open, you’ll get good people-watching between spoonfuls. Pair it with a quick walk to the harbor for easy photos and a shot of the Ego Alley boat traffic.
Best Crab Restaurants in Annapolis (Map)
Best Annapolis Restaurants (For Crab Soup):
Boatyard Bar & Grill
McGarvey’s
O’Brien’s
Middleton Tavern
Federal House
